Beyond Institutions: Meeting Gen Z in Their Search for Hope
/
How church leaders can embody credible faith for a generation that craves authenticity
There's a paradox at the heart of Gen Z spirituality. This generation, born between 1997 and 2012, is more spiritually curious than many assume. They ask deep questions about meaning, purpose and what matters. Yet they deeply distrust institutions, including the church. Recent research from Business Insider shows that Gen Z trusts traditional structures less than any generation before them.
For those of us in church leadership, this is both a challenge and an invitation. How can we offer a credible, authentic vision of Christian faith to young people who value lived integrity over inherited authority? The answer may lie not in defending the institutional church, but in pointing this generation afresh to Jesus Christ through His living Word.
Understanding Gen Z's spiritual landscape
To engage Gen Z authentically, we first need to understand what shapes their approach to faith. This generation has grown up amid multiple crises: economic instability, a pandemic that disrupted their formative years, and an epidemic of anxiety. They've witnessed institutional failures and learned to question what previous generations took for granted.
Yet this scepticism doesn't mean they don't care about spirituality. Gen Z values personal meaning, inclusion and authenticity. They care deeply about integrity, the gap between what we claim and how we live.
There's something biblical about this attitude. The prophets called God's people back from empty religion to hearts transformed by God (Isaiah 1:11-17). Jesus saved his harshest words not for doubters but for religious hypocrisy (Matthew 23:27-28). Perhaps Gen Z's scepticism challenges us to genuinely embody the gospel we proclaim.
This generation hungers for hope. But real hope doesn’t come from better circumstances or closer communities - it’s found in a person. Jesus gives us true and lasting hope, not simply by modelling sacrificial love, but by being the sacrifice that made a way for us to live in the fullness of God’s everlasting hope.
Why institutions struggle to connect
Why do traditional forms of church so often fail to connect with young people?
Is there too much emphasis on authority structures rather than real relationships? Gen Z can fact-check claims instantly and spot fake authenticity. When church presents itself primarily through hierarchies, it triggers their distrust. They're not asking "Who's in charge?" but "Who can I trust?"
Second, many churches have relied on programmes over presence. We create youth groups, but if these feel like systems rather than spaces where they're genuinely known, they ring hollow.
Third, church communication can feel disconnected from real life. When young people are dealing with anxiety, loneliness and questions about identity, teaching that ignores these realities creates distance.
Yet here's the opportunity: the incarnation offers a different model. God came among us, Emmanuel (Matthew 1:23). Jesus entered into human experience and relationship, meeting people in their mess and doubt. His credibility came from embodying divine love, and ultimately from going to the cross to deal with our deepest problem: separation from God.
The credibility gap facing the church today is an invitation to rediscover what it means to point people to Christ with truth and grace (John 1:14).
Hope in the Gospel
Conversations with youth workers across the UK and Ireland led to the development of HOPE, a three-part short film series exploring uncertainty, despair and spiritual searching. But these films aren't just about exploring questions, they're designed to point young people toward answers found in Scripture.
The series helps young people understand what hope really is, why we desperately need it , and where true hope is found: in the gospel of Jesus Christ, His death on the cross and His resurrection. As Romans 5:8 reminds us, "God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us."
Each film is paired with Bible study materials that take young people deeper into God's Word, inviting them to wrestle with Scripture for themselves. This is where the real work happens, opening the Bible and encountering Jesus there, where He speaks by His Spirit through His living Word.
What makes this approach worth noting? First, the series uses story and image to create an entry point for biblical exploration. Gen Z has grown up in a visual culture. Jesus taught primarily through parables. These films use contemporary storytelling to draw young people in, and then the studies guide them to see what God's Word says.
Second, the resources create space for open and authentic questioning, recognising that faith grows through conversation as well as reflection on Scripture. As young people engage together, the Holy Spirit gently reveals truth and anchors their hope more deeply in Jesus. These are films that make faith conversations possible.
Church leaders can learn from this. What if we used creative storytelling as a bridge to biblical truth?
Practical Guidance for Leaders
So what does this look like in practice? Here are five principles for engaging Gen Z:
Lead with authenticity. Be vulnerable and honest about your own spiritual life. Share your struggles, but always pointing back to Christ and Scripture. Gen Z are drawn to leaders genuinely working out what it means to live under the authority of God's Word.
Put relationship before programme. Build trust through consistent, genuine presence. Show up. Listen more than you speak. But remember that the goal is to walk alongside young people as they encounter Jesus.
Invite participation, not just attendance. Involve young people in shaping how faith is explored in your community. Ask: "Is there another way we could explore the Bible together?” Let them wrestle with it.
Ground everything in Scripture. Show that Christian hope isn't based on our feelings or good works but is anchored in what God has done for us in Christ. As we live out the gospel in sacrificial service, we point beyond ourselves to the Savior. Real hope comes from understanding our deep need for Jesus and being confident in his finished work at the cross.
Create space for biblical exploration. Use film, art, music, and dialogue as entry points to Scripture. Resources like HOPE can open doors that traditional teaching alone might not reach, but ensure there's always a clear pathway to engaging with God's Word itself.
Faith Lived Out in Community
The church's credibility with Gen Z ultimately depends on embodying the gospel we proclaim and consistently pointing people to encounter Jesus in His Word. Perhaps this generation is calling us back to something essential: that there is power in Scripture, that God speaks by His Spirit through the Bible, and that authentic Christian community forms when people genuinely engage with biblical truth together.
The gospel has always spoken most powerfully into hopelessness because it offers real, Christ-centered hope. Not optimism, but hope: the conviction that God is at work even in darkness, that Jesus died for our sins and rose again, that He is making all things new (Revelation 21:5).
Young people today need to meet Christians for whom hope isn't just a feeling but a reality anchored in Christ's finished work. They need faith communities where people genuinely care for one another because they've encountered God's love in Christ, where honesty is welcomed, where Scripture is opened and explored together.
As we live out the gospel, serving sacrificially as Jesus did, we must remember that our good works don't save us or anyone else. Only Jesus saves. We serve because we've been transformed by the gospel, and our lives point to the Savior who gave everything for us.
Perhaps the future of faith with Gen Z will be less about institution and more about incarnation, faith lived out in authentic community centered on Christ and His Word. This generation is inviting us to rediscover what the early church knew: that Christianity spreads most powerfully through transformed lives, communities shaped by Scripture, and the proclamation that Jesus Christ is Lord.
The question for church leaders isn't "How do we get young people back into our institutions?" but "How do we help young people encounter Jesus in His living Word, where He will speak by His Spirit and transform their lives?"
Gen Z isn't rejecting faith. They're looking for authenticity, for space to wrestle with biblical truth, for communities where the gospel is both proclaimed and lived out. That's not a problem. It's an opportunity.
About the author
Jenny Hamill leads the Creative Team in Scripture Union Scotland, continuing to oversee Digital Content Development, alongside Communications and Magnitude events.
HOPE is a three-part short film series from Shine Films, a partnership of SU movements and youth organisations across the UK and Ireland. The films explore uncertainty, despair and spiritual searching, pointing young people toward the hope found in the gospel. Each film is accompanied by Bible study materials that take young people deeper into God's Word, based on key biblical passages. Freely available at shinefilms.org/hope.
